Home Show Review — Extreme Makeover: Home Edition

ExtremesmallAre you sick to death of the manipulation of your emotions, the contrived tear-jerking scenes, the blatant product placement that is rampant on Extreme Makeover: Home Edition?

I’m not. Though when I saw the first show, I was horrified to see the crew mow down the old house and build a McMansion on the lot with no regard for finances or reality. What kind of home makeover is that?

Of course, it’s not a home makeover so much as a life makeover for folks who are hurting. Some memorable episodes: the demoralized paraplegic female cop who could not move her wheelchair through the old house, and the paraplegic ex-drill sergeant with the same problem. How could you not get teary watching these people behold their newly functional homes, and lives?

I guess that’s it. I like to feel. I like sappy stuff, whereas my husband hates it. I do wonder about the off-camera drama we don’t see: the people who feel taken advantage of or tossed aside, the original homes who served their purposes well but are callously trashed. Can we not have a moment of silence for them? This show may be like sausage and politics, where you don’t really want to know how it’s done.

P.S. What home improvement shows are you watching these days?

Read more Television posts

3 Comments on Home Show Review — Extreme Makeover: Home Edition

  1. Divan Beds

    Well, I love the show because of the designs they do on those “dull” homes. I guess that is the only reason I watch the show.

  2. Robin

    Please check out this link. It’s pretty disturbing – re: dangerous information on the May 4 episode of Extreme Makeover Home Edition

  3. Betty B

    I’m tired of the sob stories and the way that the show makes it seem like everyone out there cares and is willing to lend a helping hand. And why should the people who are selected for the Home Makeover deserve a dream home of such magntitude just because they have a blind kid or some other hard luck story? Life is hard for all of us. A lot of us have debilitating maladies.
    I have a severe hormone disorder that makes me ill all of the time, chronic fatigue syndrome, fibromyalgia, and depression that’s so bad that I can barely function. No one is building me a dream home to make my life easy and merry. No one gives a damn!